Journal of Evolutionary Biology

Transgenerational plasticity (TGP)- when parental environments influence offspring phenotypes - is ubiquitous across taxonomic groups and can have benefits for offspring beyond what is possible with developmental plasticity, particularly when selective pressures are high early in life. However, patterns of TGP vary widely across populations and species, and the evolutionary processes shaping this variation remain poorly understood. Here, we tested whether repeated evolutionary transitions result in parallel or population-specific evolutionary divergence in TGP relative to ancestral conditions. We examined sperm-mediated paternal effects across two ancestral marine and three derived freshwater populations of threespined stickleback fish (Gasterosteus aculeatus). We exposed fathers to dragonfly larvae (endemic to freshwater) or sculpin (endemic to all populations) predators and measured both paternal response to predators as well as antipredator behavior and growth in larval offspring. Fathers behaviorally responded to the presence of sculpin predators, but not dragonfly larvae. However, we found strong paternal effects in response to both predators in all populations. Further, the magnitude of TGP did not differ between marine and freshwater populations, suggesting that TGP does not become genetically accommodated as marine populations move into freshwater habitats. We found some evidence consistent with parallelism in both within and trans-generational plasticity: 1) personal exposure of larval stickleback to dragonfly larvae elicited strong antipredator responses in freshwater populations that were absent in marine populations, and 2) paternal predation exposure consistently increased offspring growth in marine populations while slowing growth in freshwater populations. In contrast, paternal effects altered offspring behavior in population-specific ways, with strong sex-specific effects of paternal exposure emerging in response to endemic predators. Adaptive evolution is a two-step process, in which heritable genotypic and phenotypic variation must first be present and then selected on. Therefore, high population-level variation in TGP suggests the capacity for rapid evolution of parental effects, while signatures of parallelism and sex-specific patterns suggest that TGP may evolve in targeted ways in response to ecological stressors.

Copper is an essential micronutrient in most organisms that becomes toxic in large quantities. Repeated or prolonged sub-lethal exposure can lead to evolved resistance to copper toxicity over many generations, which may result in trade-offs between energetically expensive detoxification mechanisms and fitness. Alternatively, evolved resistance to chemical stressors may lead to correlated changes in other traits. This study focuses on a population of flies for which artificial selection for copper resistance led to an increase in both copper resistance and longevity. The apparent off-target benefit of copper selection on one component of fitness led us to investigate differences in fecundity and developmental viability in copper resistant and copper sensitive, non-selected populations. We assessed the effect of copper selection and copper exposure on multiple aspects of fecundity over the lifespans of females from the non-selected and copper-selected populations. Our study corroborated previously observed increased longevity in copper-selected flies. Controlling for variation in lifespan, copper-resistant females had comparable age-matched fecundity to copper-sensitive females and benefitted from increased longevity with higher lifetime fecundity. Overall, copper exposure negatively affected egg quality, but we found no difference in this trait between the copper-resistant and sensitive populations. Further, we found developmental viability under copper stress was significantly higher for eggs laid by copper-resistant females. Overall, we determined that copper resistant flies experienced a fitness benefit through both lifespan and fecundity. Costs of maintaining copper resistance may be associated with energetic costs, but these trade-offs may not always manifest in reproductive or lifespan fitness costs.

Allee effects are positive relationships between components of individual fitness and the number or density of individuals in a population. Negative density effects are well documented in Drosophila melanogaster across life stages, while Allee effects are rare and largely confined to the larval stages. However, despite the costs of high density, adult flies are found to exhibit attraction to same-sex conspecifics, suggesting some fitness value to the presence of conspecifics. We measured fitness related traits of singly mated-females housed at same-sex densities of 1, 2, or 10 and found clear reductions in lifetime reproductive output at low densities. Additionally, these females concentrated reproductive effort within early adulthood, albeit without improving estimates of fitness. When housed at variable densities, females altered their reproductive output in response to immediate densities, but were unable to improve it unless remating was possible, indicating an interaction between mating and density. Overall, our findings suggest that reproductive plasticity in response to the presence of conspecifics mediates positive effects of density on fitness in female Drosophila melanogaster. Understanding the physiological and ecological bases of such plasticity may help explain the evolution of social tendency in the fly.

Phenotypic differences among populations can arise through heritable genetic divergence, phenotypic plasticity, or both, making it difficult to determine whether trait-environment correlations observed in nature reflect adaptive evolution. Within threespine stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus) studies, numerous document morphological differences among allopatric-, parapatric-, and even sympatric populations. These phenotypic differences among populations are often correlated with diet and lake habitat (e.g., lake size), suggesting an adaptive value to the population differences. However, many studies of ecomorphological divergence in stickleback use wild-caught stickleback, which may differ due to evolution or plasticity. Although common garden experiments have confirmed that population differences can be heritable, such experiments typically entail small numbers of populations. Consequently, we still do not know to what extent well-known trait-environment correlations in stickleback are a result of evolution. To address this gap, we reared stickleback embryos from 27 lake populations on Vancouver Island, in a laboratory environment. Morphological differences among populations persist in common-garden fish, confirming a large role for divergent evolution. These heritable differences were associated with environmental variation among lakes, implying an adaptive value. However, some well-known trait-environment relationships in stickleback did not persist in common-garden fish and may be primarily plastic.

Understanding how divergence in reproductive traits can promote speciation remains a fundamental question in evolutionary biology. Sperm morphology and kinematics diverge rapidly across species. However, the effect of hybridization between recently diverged species on sperm traits remains unclear, limiting our understanding of how reproductive isolation evolves. Here, we evaluated sperm morphology, kinematics, and trait integration in species of a young (~10,000 years), sympatric Cyprinodon pupfish radiation from San Salvador Island, Bahamas, as well as fertile advanced-generation hybrids between two of these species. We found significant divergence in flagellum length, midpiece area, and sperm velocity among species. In contrast, hybrids displayed transgressive kinematic profiles defined by high velocities, reduced path curvature, and distinct patterns of sperm kinematic integration. Our findings suggest that hybridization between recently diverged species may reorganize the underlying control of sperm locomotor mechanisms, generating novel phenotypes that could contribute to reproductive isolation in the early stages of speciation.

The evolutionary patterns of trait diversification provide insights into the function of the trait. Early burst of trait evolution is often associated with adaptive radiation, rapidly diversifying the trait in response to vacant niches followed by the slowdown of the diversification with niche filling, whereas late burst is more likely to be associated with sexual selection, possibly contributing to reproductive barriers between closely related species. Here, we studied the diversification of tail fork depth through time in hirundines to infer its function, which remains unclear due to the competing two alternative hypotheses: the sexual selection hypothesis, which is a classic explanation of deeply forked tails, proposed that this trait has evolved via sexual selection, which was then challenged by the viability selection hypothesis, which proposed that deeply forked tails have mainly evolved via viability selection for enhancing aerodynamic performance during aerial foraging on large prey. We found a late burst of tail fork depth, but not of bill length, i.e., an index of prey size. The observed pattern is consistent with the sexual selection hypothesis but not with the viability selection hypothesis.

Parental qualities can influence the development and fitness of their offspring via genetic and non-genetic effects. Although these effects are often linked to parental phenotypes, the effect of parental genetic variation linked with relevant phenotypes is less well understood. We performed full factorial crosses based on parental genotypes for an age-at-maturity-related gene, vgll3, to investigate how the parental genotypes influence Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) offspring survival, growth, and development in their early life. Beyond the connection with age at maturity, the additional association between vgll3 and body condition in Atlantic salmon offers a potential pathway by which the maternal vgll3 genotype could influence offspring early life fitness. Combined with measurements of maternal phenotype and egg characteristics, the crossing design therefore allowed us to disentangle the maternal and paternal genetic and non-genetic contributions to variation in offspring survival and phenotypic traits. The phenotypic traits measured were hatching length and yolk sac area, growth, and yolk sac consumption and conversion efficiency. Parental vgll3 genotype did not influence the majority of our measured egg traits or alevin traits except for a genetic effect of paternal vgll3 genotype on offspring survival, whereby the paternal late maturation allele was associated with higher survival. Maternal effects were strongest for survival and for traits associated with hatching and weaker for alevin growth and yolk sac usage. Paternal effects on the measured alevin traits were negligible. The results from our study demonstrate that both maternal and paternal effects have the potential to influence offspring early life fitness traits.

Dominance is a widespread feature of genetic variants which affects life-history traits and fitness. Although dominance is generally thought to be an intrinsic property of genetic variants, it can sometimes evolve, as in the classic case of melanism in the peppered moth. The broader question of how likely dominance is to evolve is, however, controversial, because conditions favouring dominance evolution are often restrictive. Here, we revisit Haldanes classic hypothesis that dominance might evolve during the spread of beneficial mutations to fixation (i.e., during selective sweeps). We first confirm results of earlier models that sweeps of unconditionally beneficial mutations generate little potential for dominance to evolve, even in cases where modifier alleles segregate prior to selective sweeps. However, when sweeping beneficial alleles trade off between different environments -- which we explore with the illustrative case of sexually antagonistic selection -- the scope for dominance evolution expands. This occurs because modifier alleles can alter dominance separately in each environment, increasing the mean fitness of heterozygotes, prolonging the sojourn time of the sweep, and generating more heterozygosity upon which the modifier can act. In extreme cases, beneficial mutations that were initially destined for fixation can undergo a "dominance reversal" as a result of dominance evolution, converting them to balanced polymorphisms. We quantify how regularly dominance reversals of sweeping sexually antagonistic alleles can be expected to evolve. Overall, our results highlight conditions that allow the dominance of beneficial mutations to evolve, which we discuss in light of data on the frequency of selective sweeps, standing genetic variation for modifiers, and plasticity of modifier effects.

Rapid evolution allows populations to persist in environments where they would otherwise go extinct. This phenomenon, known as evolutionary rescue, is typically studied in the framework of biological evolution, yet adaptive traits can also arise and spread through cultural evolution. The present study developed a stochastic eco-evolutionary model to compare rescue probabilities through biological and cultural evolution. Transmission bias governed the rescue probability under cultural evolution by setting how readily a rare adaptive trait was copied. Conformity bias suppressed population persistence because a rare trait was the least likely to be copied. Content bias toward the adaptive trait enabled evolutionary rescue when social learning was rapid, but it typically yielded a lower rescue probability than biological evolution. Only anticonformity bias, together with a high social learning rate, exceeded the rescue probability of biological evolution by enabling the adaptive trait to be established more rapidly. These results demonstrate that transmission bias alters the demographic consequences of cultural evolution and highlight the importance of transmission processes in evolutionary rescue theory. Understanding how adaptive behaviours are socially transmitted may also improve predictions of animal population persistence and inform conservation efforts in rapidly changing environments.

Phenotypic plasticity, the ability of a single genotype to produce alternative phenotypes in response to environmental cues, is a key driver of evolutionary change. In the water strider Microvelia longipes, males display remarkable continuous variation in hindleg length, a sexually selected trait used as a weapon in male/male contests for access to females. To determine whether DNA methylation mediates this environmentally induced phenotypic variation, we used three inbred lines of M. longipes that differ in mean hindleg length, body size, and allometric coefficients. We performed whole-genome bisulfite sequencing on adult males and females from all lines, and tested the effect of nutritional treatment on DNA methylation patterns. Our analysis identified 12,684,876 CpG 12% of which were methylated. This global level of DNA methylation is among the highest reported in insects. DNA methylation was predominantly concentrated within or near gene bodies (77% of methylated CpGs), consistent with patterns observed in other insects. Unsupervised clustering and principal component analyses revealed that methylation patterns differed significantly between genetic lines but showed minimal differences between sexes, indicating a strong genetic influence. Most surprisingly, despite nutrition having a pronounced effect on leg length, we observed no significant changes in DNA methylation in response to dietary treatment. These results show that in M. longipes, DNA methylation patterns are largely stable across environmental conditions and primarily determined by genetic background. This challenges the common assumption that DNA methylation universally mediates environmentally induced phenotypic plasticity and suggests that other epigenetic mechanisms, such as histone modifications or non-coding RNAs, may play a more direct role in regulating continuous plastic traits. Our study underscores the complexity of epigenetic regulation and highlights the need for broader investigation of molecular pathways to fully understand the molecular basis of phenotypic variation in natural populations.

Animal colouration evolves under multiple, often conflicting, selective pressures. Conspicuous, non-aposematic colour-patterns that enhance conspecific communication may simultaneously increase detectability by predators. Such trade-offs can be resolved by optimising colour-patterns to match the perceptual abilities of different receivers. We tested whether dorsal colour-patterns of the Lusitanian wall lizard (Podarcis lusitanicus) are optimised for ecologically relevant receivers across relevant viewing distances, while accounting for the visual acuity of conspecifics and predators. Conspecifics and snakes detected chromatic information at shorter distances, whereas achromatic and luminance information were detected at longer distances. Birds showed a uniform decline in detectability across the colour-pattern components with increasing viewing distance. Larger males retained high chromatic detectability across all receivers despite the general distance-related decline, whereas females and smaller individuals exhibited less salient colour patterns, consistent with predator avoidance strategy. Our results show that lizards resolve the trade-off between conspecific communication and predator detection through distance-dependent colour-pattern perceptibility across receivers. This resolution breaks down in large males, for whom the benefits of salient chromatic patterns for intraspecific communication may outweigh increased detectability to predators.

A long-standing question in evolutionary biology is: Under what circumstances can speciation occur despite hybridisation or because of hybridisation? Some models of hybrid incompatibilities predict that speciation can occur even in the presence of gene flow and strong selection against hybrids, an outcome also influenced by genetic contributions from parental species and genetic architecture. On the other hand, empirical work has shown that heterosis can counteract the effect of incompatibilities, hindering the speciation process. Theoretical models that simultaneously consider the positive and negative impacts of hybridisation on fitness remain scarce, raising questions about the effects of hybrid incompatibilities in the presence of heterosis. To address this question, we study how (Bateson)-Dobzhansky-Muller incompatibilities (BDMIs) interact with overdominant mutations in a two-locus population genetics model of an isolated hybrid population. We find that the strength of overdominance relative to incompatibilities determines the long-term genetic composition of the hybrid population. We show that high recombination exposes incompatibilities to selection and reduces the frequency of derived alleles in the hybrid population, limiting the strength of BDMIs that can be maintained by the balance with overdominance. We also show how neutral variation is affected by the strength of selection and the recombination rate between incompatible loci, generating patterns that include an increase in local variation resembling associative overdominance, or a reduction resembling background selection. Such variation of neutral variation, particularly at intermediate distances from BDMI loci, can generate peaks or troughs of diversity that are explained by the recombination rate between BDMI loci, and initial proportions of admixture between parental populations. Our work demonstrates how the genomic conflict caused by the interplay of overdominance and hybrid incompatibilities, recombination, and parental contributions, shape the genome of an isolated hybrid population.

Cross-feeding relationships shape the composition of many microbial communities, yet the evolutionary processes that give rise to them remain poorly understood. Most theoretical and experimental work has therefore focused on minimal scenarios, particularly the stable cross-feeding polymorphisms that evolve in asexual populations growing on a single energy source (Helling et al., 1987). Yet replicate experiments do not always produce cross-feeding populations, raising the question of why genetically identical populations evolving under identical conditions can follow different evolutionary trajectories (Treves et al., 1998). Here we present a bare-bones agent-based model of evolution in a chemostat. We show that selection for energy acquisition alone is sufficient to promote the evolution of cross-feeding, without invoking mechanisms specific to metabolic exchange. The resulting communities nevertheless differ across replicate simulations, reproducing the qualitative variability observed experimentally. Significance StatementMicrobial communities often depend on cross-feeding, in which one cells metabolic product becomes anothers energy source. Existing explanations typically invoke trade-offs between metabolic tasks or other mechanisms specific to cross-feeding itself. Using large-scale in silico simulations of evolution in a chemostat, we show that no such explanation is required. A population that competes for metabolic energy by utilizing a primary resource and then releasing a product that may itself serve as an energy source can evolve into a mixed population of organisms that specialize in the primary resource alongside others that specialize in the secondary one. Energy-based probabilistic death and reproduction are sufficient to produce this coexistence and to reproduce the mixed outcomes seen in laboratory evolution experiments.

Plumage pigmentation is under intense sexual and natural selection and plays an important role in the speciation process in birds, so there is much interest in uncovering the genomic basis of plumage colour differences between populations and species. Three species of North American woodpeckers, the red-breasted (Sphyrapicus ruber), red-naped (S. nuchalis), and yellow-bellied sapsuckers (S. varius), provide a particularly promising opportunity to unravel the genomic mechanisms of plumage colour differentiation. The breeding ranges of the three species are mostly non-overlapping but adjacent, with hybrid zones occurring where the ranges meet. The species pair with the most similar plumage colouration (S. varius and S. nuchalis) is not the most closely related pair genomically (S. nuchalis and S. ruber is), providing an opportunity to determine the subset of the genome that underlies the plumage colour variation. Using admixture mapping of whole genome sequences from each species and hybrids from each species pair, we show close associations between the colour of multiple plumage patches and wide swathes of the Z-chromosome. These results highlight how comparable changes in one sex chromosome can cause either slight plumage pigmentation changes (S. varius vs. S. nuchalis) or large-scale shifts from dimorphism to monomorphism and from primarily black and white to primarily red plumage colouration (S. varius and S. nuchalis vs. S. ruber).

The evolution of recombination is thought to be influenced by many factors, including the mating system. Here, we provide an experimental test of how self-fertilization (selfing) affects the evolution of a recombination modifier. We used experimental populations of Caenorhabditis elegans segregating for the recombination modifier rec-1, a mutant that redistributes crossovers from the genetically diverse chromosome arms toward the less diverse central regions. By evolving populations under varying selfing rates, we show that increasing selfing reverses selection acting on the rec-1 mutant, from positive to negative. Simulations show that this reversal can be explained by an expansion of the genomic region over which the modifier remains associated with the genetic combinations it creates. These results demonstrate that selfing can fundamentally alter the evolutionary fate of recombination modifiers and reveal a mechanism not predicted by previous theoretical models of recombination evolution under different mating systems, which assumed uniform recombination landscapes.

Sexually selected traits often impose fitness costs on their bearers. Yet, the relative costs and benefits of conspicuous traits can vary through space and time, driving variation in selection acting on those traits. For insects, an important but overlooked source of such variation is seasonal shifts in the local abundance of migratory insectivorous birds. Smoky rubyspot damselflies (Hetaerina titia) exhibit a marked seasonal polyphenism in wing pigmentation throughout much of North America, with individuals emerging in the summer exhibiting conspicuous dark wings. Here, we test the hypothesis that this variation is an adaptive response to seasonal and geographical variation in predation risk. First, we find evidence for strong constraints acting on wing phenotypes outside of the summer season, consistent with a seasonal shift in the relative costs and benefits of pigmentation. Second, using a continentally distributed predation experiment, we find that predation risk covaries with spatiotemporal variation in wing pigmentation and is linked to shifts in the local abundance of migratory birds. Overall, our analyses establish an eco-evolutionary link between tropical and temperate regions, underscoring the importance of considering both the evolutionary and ecological consequences of spatiotemporal variation in biotic interactions as species assemblages shift in response to global change.

Reputation plays a major role in supporting cooperation among unrelated individuals through indirect reciprocity. By helping others, individuals build a good personal reputation and receive greater benefits from future partners. Most models of indirect reciprocity assume that a person's reputation reflects only their own behaviour. Yet in many societies, people are also judged by their family's reputation. How family reputation affects the evolution of cooperation, and whether reliance on it can itself evolve, remain unclear. Here we show that reputation inheritance expands the conditions under which indirect reciprocity favours cooperation, increasing helping and favouring greater reciprocity. Greater reciprocity in turn favours stronger reliance on inherited reputation, creating a positive feedback that stabilises cooperation, especially when interactions are infrequent or personal behaviour is difficult to observe. This feedback arises because cooperation generates future benefits both for the individual, through their personal reputation, and for their descendants, through inherited reputation. Reputation inheritance thereby provides a route via which kin selection and reciprocity, often treated as alternative explanations for cooperation, can reinforce one another. Our model helps explain why family-based reputation occurs across diverse human societies and provides an evolutionary framework for studying phenomena organised around family standing, including kin-based institutions, feuds between families and honour-based violence within them.

Understanding how populations persist in gradually deteriorating environments through evolution is a central question in ecology and evolutionary biology. Previous studies have primarily focused on identifying the critical rate of environmental change beyond which extinction is certain. However, the existence of a viable equilibrium when the rate is below the threshold does not guarantee that a population can survive the transient dynamics to reach it. Using a quantitative genetic model that explicitly incorporates feedback among population size, genetic variance, and mean trait evolution, we show that population persistence can exhibit bistability when the rate of environmental change is below the extinction threshold. Specifically, extinction still occurs if the initial population size and genetic variance fall below a critical level. The initial state also influences the eco-evolutionary dynamics, such that a temporary increase or decline in population size and/or genetic variance does not necessarily predict the ultimate fate of the population. Therefore, in addition to estimating the critical rate of environmental change for extinction, characterizing current population size, genetic variation, and the degree of maladaptation may improve predictions of extinction risk in deteriorating environments.

1. Plants produce a great chemodiversity, which is the diversity of specialized metabolites (SMs). These SMs are produced in complex metabolic pathways and play an important role in inter-species interactions. There are numerous hypotheses about the evolutionary processes which brought about and maintain chemodiversity. Some have been partially tested in lab and field studies. However, some of their assumptions and predictions are better tested by quantitative modeling, and so far no quantitative model has investigated the role of metabolic pathways. 2. To close this gap, we developed an individual-based model for metabolic pathway evolution. It models enzymes creating metabolites with various modifications. Enzymes undergo inheritance and mutation. We used the model to compare the screening and interaction diversity hypotheses. 3. The screening hypothesis predicts promiscuous enzymes, genetic drift, the presence of many non-beneficial metabolites, and high metabolite richness. The interaction diversity hypothesis predicts specialized enzymes, selection, the almost exclusive presence of beneficial metabolites, and situation- dependent metabolite richness. We found that the patterns predicted by the screening hypothesis did not occur, while those predicted by the interaction diversity hypothesis did. 4. This provides reason to favor the interaction diversity hypothesis over the screening hypothesis when connecting empirical results to their evolutionary context

Sensory systems mediate the interaction between organisms and their environment, but how complex sensory pathways evolve and relate to variation in perception and behavior across ecological contexts, remains poorly understood, especially for terrestrial taxa. Here, we investigate whole-visual-system adaptation in Heliconius erato butterflies. Using continent-wide sampling, we demonstrate that within H. erato, facet count significantly decreased with increasing elevation. Common-garden rearing of low-elevation H. erato populations from Ecuador and their high-elevation sister species, H. himera, showed that eye and brain morphology are heritable, and comparisons to genomic measures of divergence indicates that this variation is due to divergent selection. Parallel comparisons from Colombia involving H. chestertonii (high elevation) and H. erato venus (low elevation) further revealed that eye and brain morphology can evolve as independent, decoupled traits. For both locations, differences in visual acuity correlated with variation in facet count. We also observed parallel evolution of spectral sensitivity, with independent high-elevation populations having fewer red-reflecting lateral filtering pigments. To experimentally link visual system morphology to behavior, we assessed visual acuity in second-generation H. erato cyrbia-H. himera hybrids. Overall, acuity was influenced by facet count, and when analyzed together with brain morphology, by a positive interaction between facet count and optic lobe volume, demonstrating that structural investment in the eye and neural expansion combine to maximize visual perception. This work shows that visual adaptation is a multi-layered process whereby sensory traits can evolve independently under localized ecological pressures, but evolution across the visual pathway contributes to refinements in behavioral performance.